Marker Ridge is the newest set of townhomes in the Village of Irvington. They are two-story homes built by Toll Brothers, each with three bedrooms, three and a half baths, a home office, a basement and a two-car garage, and the builder handles lawn care and snow removal. Site work was announced in March 2025. When the model opened in April 2025, Toll Brothers set the starting price at $1.6 million. The builder's community page now lists the community as sold out. From here on, a Marker Ridge home comes up only when an owner decides to sell.
That turns Marker Ridge into a reference price for the rest of Irvington's attached housing. A buyer who wants a low-maintenance home in the village is choosing between it and three older condominium communities: Downingwood, Pennybridge Manor and the Fieldpoint townhouses. On closed prices, the new homes cost about twice as much. Measured per square foot, the two groups are much closer.
What Each Community Closed At
Every figure below is a closed sale. Marker Ridge's eight closings fall between January and September 2026, from a OneKey MLS sales report for the Irvington School District. The older communities' figures cover each one's most recent closings, as dated in the table.
| Community | Era | Sales and window | Size range | Closed price range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marker Ridge | Built 2025–2026 | 8 sales, Jan.–Sept. 2026 | 2,675–3,325 sq. ft. | $1,499,000–$1,959,000 |
| Downingwood | Built 1979 | 8 sales, Dec. 2025–Aug. 2026 | 1,400–2,221 sq. ft. | $635,000–$1,036,000 |
| Fieldpoint townhouses | Phases launched 1987–1988 | 7 sales, July 2025–June 2026 | 1,423–2,230 sq. ft. | $660,000–$1,155,555 |
| Pennybridge Manor | Developed c. 1988 | 2 sales, Nov. 2025 and June 2026 | 2,014–2,195 sq. ft. | $800,000–$837,800 |
The middle sale at Marker Ridge in those nine months works out to about $1.78 million. The middle Downingwood sale over its eight closings is about $937,000. That is a gap of roughly 90 percent.
Divide by the Square Foot and Most of the Gap Disappears
The size column explains most of the price column. Every Marker Ridge home that closed in 2026 was at least 2,675 square feet, and half of them were 3,325. No townhouse in the other three communities that closed in the windows above was larger than 2,230 square feet.
Per square foot, Marker Ridge's eight closings ran from about $500 to about $720, with the middle near $617. Downingwood's eight ran from about $377 to about $561, with the middle near $460. So the per-foot difference is closer to a third than to double. The two ranges also overlap. The 1,800-square-foot Downingwood unit at 72 Quail Close sold for $990,000 in July 2026, or about $550 a foot. The 3,325-square-foot Marker Ridge home at 17 Marker Ridge sold for $1,669,000 after 148 days on the market, or about $502 a foot.
Fieldpoint shows the same overlap. 55 Ridgeway Drive, a 1,677-square-foot townhouse, closed at $1,155,555 in December 2025. That is about $689 a foot, inside Marker Ridge's range. At the low end, 31 Westwood Close closed in February 2026 at $660,000 for 1,456 square feet, about $453 a foot.
For a buyer comparing these communities, that means most of the extra $800,000 or so pays for an extra 1,000 square feet or more. The premium for being brand new is a smaller share. Pricing a 1,700-square-foot Downingwood or Fieldpoint unit against a Marker Ridge listing on the total price alone overstates how much the new construction costs per foot.
What the Extra Space and Newer Build Include
Every Marker Ridge home has a basement, a two-car garage and a dedicated home office as standard features. Those features account for some of the extra square footage, and they are part of what the per-foot premium pays for.
The older communities have shared facilities instead. Downingwood sits on 32 acres next to the Halsey Pond Preserve and has a pool, two tennis courts, a playground, a clubhouse, a gym and a game room. Water and basic cable are included in its common charges. Fieldpoint is within walking distance of Main Street and less than a mile from the Irvington Metro-North station, and has a pool, a clubhouse, an exercise room, a sauna and tennis courts. Pennybridge Manor has its own pool and is close to Metro-North and to trails such as the Old Croton Aqueduct Trailway.
At Marker Ridge you pay for more space inside your own home. At the older communities you pay less and get a pool and tennis courts shared across the complex.
Where Marker Ridge Overlaps With Single-Family Houses
The Marker Ridge price range also matches part of Irvington's single-family market. A OneKey-based monthly report from local market tracker Homix puts the village's single-family median sale price at $1,664,498 for the 12 months through October 2026. That is within the range of the eight Marker Ridge closings.
Individual sales show what a similar budget bought elsewhere in Irvington in the first nine months of 2026. 153 Fieldpoint Drive, a 4-bedroom detached house of 3,148 square feet, sold for $1,562,500. That is about $496 a foot, below every Marker Ridge sale on that basis. Smaller houses in the village went the other direction. 20 Riverview Road, at 1,791 square feet, closed at $1,508,000. 8 Barney Park, at 1,820 square feet, closed at $1,840,000. Those two work out to roughly $840 and $1,010 a foot.
So Marker Ridge sits in the middle on price per foot. It cost more per foot than Downingwood and less than a small single-family house in the village. In the same nine months, a detached Fieldpoint house cost less per foot than any Marker Ridge sale.
Monthly Charges From Recent Listings
Recent listings in the older communities give a sense of the monthly charges. 72 Sunnyside Place at Pennybridge Manor, which closed at $837,800 on June 23, 2026, listed common charges of $676.64 a month and 2025 property taxes of $13,090. At Fieldpoint, 116 Valleyview Road listed a $935 monthly association fee and 2025 taxes of $13,790. At Downingwood, 120 Locust Lane listed an HOA charge of $895 and taxes of $10,186. These charges come from one listing each, and the figures for any other unit will differ. They are shared here as general information and are not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the numbers for a specific home with your attorney, accountant or lender.
Few Homes for Sale This Fall
Few homes of any kind are for sale in Irvington this fall. Homix counted seven single-family homes for sale in October 2026, or 1.1 months of supply. Over the 12 months through October, single-family homes sold for 105.3 percent of their original list price on average. The same report's October single-family median was $1,080,500, based on six sales. With so few closings, a single month's median depends on which homes happened to close, and one estate sale more or less can move it by hundreds of thousands of dollars.
The attached-home market is similarly thin. As of mid-November, Downingwood had one active listing, 120 Locust Lane at $818,000 for 1,749 square feet. It has been on the market since July 17. Pennybridge Manor had no active listing. Fieldpoint's 116 Valleyview Road was under contract at an asking price of $959,000. Among new projects, the only multi-unit residential proposal reported recently is a concept for 12 or 13 apartments at 106 N. Broadway. As of Westfair's October 15 report, it was being prepared for a formal site-plan submission.
Marker Ridge sales show that the quickest ones closed well above their asking prices. 30 Marker Ridge was listed at $1,724,995 and sold for $1,929,935 after six days. 24 Marker Ridge took 175 days and closed slightly above its $1,799,000 list price. With the builder sold out, future resales will be priced against those 2026 closings.
Questions Buyers Ask About Irvington Townhomes
Were any Marker Ridge homes sold below market rate? Yes. Six affordable townhomes at 19 through 24 Marker Ridge were offered by lottery. Patch reported prices of $221,800 for the three two-bedroom units and $253,969 for the three three-bedroom units.
Does Fieldpoint include detached houses as well as townhouses? Yes. Fieldpoint has both detached single-family homes and townhouses under separate associations, and its townhouse phases launched in 1987 and 1988. The detached houses sell in a higher range, as the $1,562,500 sale at 153 Fieldpoint Drive shows.
Which older community is closest to Main Street? Of the three, Fieldpoint is the one described as within walking distance of Main Street, and it is less than a mile from the Irvington train station.
If you are deciding between a Marker Ridge resale and a larger budget at Downingwood, Fieldpoint or Pennybridge Manor, The Cindy Kief Team can work out the per-square-foot comparison for the specific homes you are considering, using the most recent closings in each community. If you already own in one of these communities, our home valuation tool is a starting point, and our Irvington neighborhood page has more on the village. Schedule a Consultation to go over the comparison with us.